whitmans_kiss: (whitman)
whitmans_kiss ([personal profile] whitmans_kiss) wrote2012-01-11 09:54 pm

Fic: BBC Sherlock, (john/sherlock), fic, "A Good Man"

Title: A Good Man
Word Count: 3,260
Author: [livejournal.com profile] whitmans_kiss
Rating: R
Warnings: major character death, suicide ideation, angst, drinking, some crude language [S1 compliant; no spoilers for S2 except the concept of Reichenbach]
Characters; Pairings: John Watson/Sherlock Holmes; D. I. Lestrade
Summary: “Sherlock Holmes is a great man - and I think one day - if we’re very, very lucky, he might even be a good one.” Lestrade calls on a grieving John.
Author's Notes: For the infinitely lovely and talented [livejournal.com profile] lotherington. Thanks go to [livejournal.com profile] ceredwensirius for the beta-work. You ladies are marvellous, and I honestly couldn’t have done it without you.
Disclaimer: Sherlock Holmes and its related characters belongs to Sir Arthur Conan Doyle and is/are not mine. The BBC incarnation of Sherlock belongs to Steven Moffat and Mark Gatiss. I make no profit from this piece of fiction. All characters are depicted are of legal age in their country, the author’s, and the reader’s.

linked/cross-posted: here at [livejournal.com profile] watsons_woes, here at [livejournal.com profile] johnsherlock, and here at [livejournal.com profile] sherlockbbc





----

Throughout the years that Lestrade had been at his job, he had seen enough sadness to last him the rest of his life – certainly longer than the lives of most of the poor souls he came across on a weekly basis. Bereaved sons, sisters, spouses – all having to be questioned, consoled. He had seen enough to know that ‘The Five Stages of Grieving’ was an utter load of shit. Grief didn’t just pass through five carefully dissected stages before it vanished; it stayed with a person forever, changing them in countless, indefinable ways, until their own death caught up with them and finally put them out of their misery. This intimacy with the effects of death and loss was encountered through Lestrade’s interactions with strangers, just faces and victims and those left behind, which was exactly why seeing it on the face of John Watson disturbed him so much.

They’d never been friends, exactly – ‘colleagues’ is about the closest Lestrade would come to putting a label on their relationship, though he suspected that the mere fact they both tolerated Sherlock’s behaviour for extended periods of time put them on a somewhat more casual level than not, if only a sort of friendship by association. They’d see each other at crime scenes, John coming along uninvited, yet still more welcome than the consulting detective he’d chosen as his companion, and Lestrade was grateful for any amount of control that John had been able to exert over the exasperating Sherlock.

But it’d been over a week since Sherlock had waltzed off to unpronounceable-where Switzerland and continued waltzing right off the edge of some bloody waterfall, leaving John empty, and Lestrade’s crime scenes just as. It felt – wrong, somehow, not having them there, and even if Lestrade knew that the likelihood of Sherlock ever coming back was zero, that still left – John.

That evening, after an afternoon of waffling and the memorial service the next day, Lestrade decides that now is as good a time as any to call on 221B and offer – what? A shoulder? As if John needed a shoulder to cry on. Perhaps an ear, instead.

Maybe just a friend.

----

Lestrade arrives at Baker Street at a quarter to nine, wondering vaguely if he should have rung John up first rather than simply showed up at his door without warning. John might not even be in, Lestrade reasons as he knocks loudly on the door, and wouldn’t that be a waste of a Tube fare.

As it turns out, Mrs. Hudson explains, the good doctor indeed isn’t home, having just stepped out to pick something up from the Tesco ‘round the corner; be back any minute. Ushering Lestrade into the hallway, Mrs. Hudson gropes for the keys to 221B.

‘I’ll let you in and wait with you in the kitchen, if you like – oh! Doctor Watson! The Inspector is here to see you. I was about to let him in and fix you both up something for when you got back.’

‘How very kind of you, Mrs. Hudson,’ John says, stepping into the tiny hall. ‘But I think I’ll take him from here.’

‘Yes, of course.’ Mrs. Hudson flashes a concerned smile at the two of them before heading back into her rooms. ‘Just call if you need anything, dears.’

‘Thank you, Mrs. Hudson.’ The door closes behind her, and it’s left to Lestrade to fumble with an explanation for his presence.

‘I have a firearm in the flat,’ John says without preamble, before Lestrade can say anything, looking him in the eye. ‘I haven’t a permit, so it’s highly illegal.’ He is perfectly calm. ‘You should probably arrest me and confiscate it.’

‘Right,’ Lestrade says, not nearly as surprised at the information that John had a gun as he should be – several things suddenly click and make absolute sense; later, they might have a quick chat about a crackshot and a cabbie – but shocked at the non sequitur nonetheless. ‘Technically, I’m off duty, but you know that doesn’t matter. Should you have just told me that?’

John wets his lips, shifts his gaze to a spot somewhere over Lestrade’s right shoulder before answering. ‘No.’ A beat. Re-established eye contact. ‘Maybe,’ John says.

‘Right, well,’ says Lestrade, pushing past him up the remaining steps to open the door, ‘I’m afraid I couldn’t hear a word you just said, what with the noise still coming up from the street, you know.’ John looks back at him. The street is quiet; the hall door behind them closed. ‘You aren’t busy tonight, are you?’

‘I have plans.’

Fuck your plans, Lestrade wants to say. ‘What plans?’ he asks instead.

‘I,’ No hesitation, just an exhale; defeat crawling in around the corners of John’s eyes, along the very set of his spine, ‘plan on getting very drunk tonight, Lestrade.’

‘There’s some luck. So was I.’

The door to the flat shuts behind them as John shows them in, and they end up in the kitchen as he puts the few items away.

‘Tea?’

‘John.’ One button, then another. Lestrade hangs his overcoat up on the back of a kitchen chair, draping it over the large, folded piece of plastic tarp already there before shrugging off his jacket and laying it across the seat. Christ. The man thought to get a bloody tarp. ‘A scotch, if you would, please. A large one; there’s a good man.’

He ignores the ammunitions clip on the table. Doesn’t even see the gun.

----

Drink in hand, Lestrade moves instinctively towards the sofa, but something in John’s face causes him to change direction mid-step and settle instead in one of the armchairs. The sofa was Sherlock’s territory, he remembers. Of course; how many times had he seen the insufferable man sprawled across the leather cushions, nothing but blue silk and soft cotton and strung out, spidery limbs?

Sitting across from him in the other chair, John leans forward to rest his arms on his thighs, cradling his small tumbler of scotch in his hands. Sherlock’s violin case rests on the low table in front of them, closed, the latches done up securely.

‘It’s been, ah, put away, then?’ asks Lestrade, gesturing to the case, desperate for something, anything to say.

‘If you mean it’s in its case and not just flung about the flat like it usually is, then yeah,’ John says, frowning. ‘Went to go get it tuned the other day at that music shop over on York Street. Violins need maintenance when no one’s playing them; sensitive to the weather, or something.’ John pauses, takes a drink, his frown deepening. ‘Bloke working there took one look at it and asked if I’d had it insured, to which I said I wasn’t sure. He sent me to Beare’s on Queen Anne Street, and that he wasn’t going to touch it without confirming I’d insured it. Couldn’t think why there’d be such a fuss over a tuning, but then one of the appraisers at Beare’s proceeded to tell me it was a bloody Stradivarius. I might not know too much about music, but I do know that name.’ Another drink. ‘I’d no idea. If Sherlock weren’t already dead, I’d kill him.’ His voice is steady, but Lestrade can hear an undercurrent of something bleak beneath the words.

‘That’s a – a what? You’re joking; how would he even get his hands on one?’

‘Don’t ask me. Same way he ever got anything else, I suppose – vaguely illegal and marginally suspect. And apparently, as I’ve been recently informed, this one in particular is worth about a million pounds. I could retire, right now, at least three times over, if I sold it.’

Lestrade actually chokes on his scotch. ‘Bloody Christ, John.’

‘I know.’

They both know it’s not about the money.

----

The silence grows oppressive. They drink a third of the bottle before John leans back in his chair and turns the telly on to a repeat of the comedy special that aired last week, the sound turned soft enough to provide a low, comforting buzz, but not loud enough for John to seriously claim he was watching it.

Once the bottle’s worked down to a half, Lestrade decides he’ll chance vocalisation.

‘I know what it’s like,’ he says, ‘to lose a brother in the line of duty.’

John looks up, at this. ‘Lestrade, it’s not – ’

‘...tell the barman... even so, because people these... when I said...’

‘His name was David,’ Lestrade continues. ‘He was my brother and the best friend I ever had. Died when he was still just a kid; twenty and a fresh face on the force.’

‘Greg,’ John tries to interrupt, and somewhere in the buzz Lestrade realizes John’s just used his first name, ‘it’s not like that; it’s nothing like that – ’

‘He always wanted to be with the police, ever since he was a boy. First time out in the uniform, he gets stabbed by some cunt just trying to break up a mugging; pulled a knife and stabbed him right in the chest – ’

‘Greg, it’s – ’

‘...and then if you think... push in my barstool... because...’

‘ – pierced a lung, punctured it. Nicked some other organs in there too; he kept – David kept a tough front in surgery, and our mum got the call first – ’

‘...now, Irish whiskey is the stuff... but if... stops your heart two drinks in...’

‘We were to be married,’ John says, the words bursting out of him in a rush, crowding out the words babbled like a failed balm from Lestrade’s mouth and the excited drone emanating from the telly. ‘Me – and Sherlock, we – were in love, and – he wasn’t my brother, and it was supposed to be tomorrow; we were going to sign the papers for a – you know, a CP. At the register’s office. Tomorrow.’

‘...always looks better after... when you stop for... she told me... – – ’

There’s a soft click as the telly shuts off. Lestrade sets the remote control down.

‘Fuck,’ he says softly.

John’s mouth twists into a contorted smile. ‘Well. Only a few times.’

At the look on Lestrade’s face, John coughs; the smile vanishes. ‘Sorry.’ He drains the rest of the scotch from the tumbler. The ice makes a brittle noise against the glass. ‘I’m sorry about your brother.’

‘It’s... it’s fine, John.’

Neither look at the other; both of their gazes land on the bottle of scotch on the table, next to the violin case.

‘I probably shouldn’t have another, should I,’ says John. It’s a statement, not a question.

‘Likely not, no.’

‘Right.’ John reaches forward, takes the bottle; leans back. Tips two fingers more of the scotch into his glass.

‘You’ll wake with a monster of a hangover.’

‘Between you and me,’ says John, almost conspiratorially, bringing the measure of scotch up to a generous three fingers, ‘I really hadn’t started drinking tonight with a plan to waking up tomorrow, so you’ll have to forgive the fact that,’ his face changes, eyes widening and mouth curving upwards, ‘I don’t really give a damn how my head feels.’

Letting out a breath on a long exhale, Lestrade takes the bottle from John when he’s finished and refreshes his own drink.

----

There’s a while before either of them speak again. It’s John who does.

‘We were going to invite you,’ he says, slowly, deliberately, clearly. Trying not to be drunk.

‘To the – thing?’ replies Lestrade, blinking, tilting his head a little more to the side to see John straightwise.

‘Just you, Mycroft, me, and him. Two witnesses, that was all we needed. But he wanted you there.’

‘Oh, John.’

‘Don’t look like that, Lestrade.’ John closes his eyes, resting. ‘It was just – you know. Supposed to be for the taxes, at first. In case something went terribly wrong on a chase, or something, then we’d be able to know if the other – in hospital – I’m sorry,’ he stops, opens his eyes, catches a wet breath in his throat.

‘It’s fine,’ Lestrade says. He wants to reach a hand out to John, to touch his shoulder, but can’t seem to find the strength to move his leaded arms.

‘It was just – going to be on paper. And then,’ John looks up, away, out the window, past the half-drawn curtains, ‘coming back here, home, after we’d given notice of our intention at the register’s, he – makes some crack about not having a bloody ring, and it’s – like it all suddenly was real in a way it hadn’t been, and that’s when I saw, and I knew – ’ he stops again, screwing his eyes shut against a shudder that runs through his chest.

‘John – ’

‘Poked around the finances and even bought myself a new suit; I said, Sherlock, you can’t expect me to wear my fatigues, and he said he didn’t care if I went naked; he much preferred me that way as it was.’ A laugh bubbles its way from John’s lips that verges on the hysterical, contained. Another shudder strikes through him. Lestrade isn’t sure if the man is about to laugh again or cry.

‘I’ll still wear the suit, but it won’t be to – ’ he continues, and there it is, a proper sob, coloured with alcohol and cheeks turned ruddy, but no tears, just clenched air forced unwillingly from his chest, like John’s fist around the glass. ‘It was supposed to be tomorrow,’ he says, fingers tighter and tighter around the tumbler, tongue looser and looser around the words, ‘We were – going to invite you, and it was supposed to be tomorrow.’

John swallows a harsh drink, and Lestrade finds that for all the times he had found himself in this situation, playing comfort to the bereaved spouse, this was his job, he had never expected to be here, sitting by John Watson with a half-empty scotch bottle and a million-pound violin between them. He always knows what to say, how to handle distress and distil information, but now, the only thing distilled is the alcohol in his system, and the only information the fact that he’s so very, very sorry for it all.

He states as much. It’s all he can do.

‘I’m sorry.’

John clenches and unclenches his left hand, the tendons flashing as tightly as the grimace splayed across his face. It’s killing him to talk like this, Lestrade knows, can see it in every line of his body, but he’s not so far gone as to recognize that it’ll kill him if he doesn’t, and he might still kill himself tonight, anyway. Lestrade doesn’t know.

‘I still wake up,’ John says, softer, though not quite so low as a whisper, ‘at half past fuck-it o' clock expecting to hear some tortured racket coming from his violin. But it's always quiet. I think that's worse.’ He blinks, his lips trembling. ‘And I still make coffee in the morning. I put the sugar out. I make the coffee, but I don’t drink it. Greg,’ and at this, John’s hand stills, and his mouth slackens, and his joints fall a single degree out of line, ‘I make it, and it just sits there in the pot all day, and I throw it out at night, and I think, what a waste it all was, what an awful, bloody, waste.

And he’s right, Lestrade thinks, as the use of past tense hurts more than an accidental present, it is a waste – a waste of a mind, of genius, of a man, of a lifetime spent solving mysteries of the people and of the heart.

And here, Lestrade knows, is Sherlock’s heart, in front of him and broken so badly it was like looking into the detective’s chest gaping open, sternum cut out with a saw and set in a dish to the side, leaving nothing but the dead space where John should have been but now sits in his armchair, drunk and yellow and bloodless.

You’re the doctor, Lestrade suddenly wants to scream, not me - you’re the bloody doctor.

----

The telly eventually finds itself turned back on, the bottle of scotch subtly nudged out of John’s reach. They talk about football, about Lestrade’s nieces coming into London for an Easter visit, about the worst lager they’d ever had, and the best, because of that one time John got stuck in Germany thanks to a misdirected plane. They don't talk about the memorial scheduled for the next afternoon.

It’s crossed over from night into morning when Lestrade’s yawning becomes a little too frequent, and John’s coherency takes a dip for the worse. John stands carefully, stretching, underestimating his balance and frowning as he staggers a step and presses a hand against the wall.

‘What’s the time?’ he asks, turning his back to Lestrade and making his way into the kitchen. The tarp crunches under Lestrade’s overcoat as John grips the back of a near chair to steady himself.

‘Getting on two,’ says Lestrade, watching John stop by the table, pick up the ammunitions clip in one hand, the gun in the other.

John makes a small sound of acknowledgement. There’s a sturdy click as he pops the clip back into the firearm.

‘You can, uh, kip on the sofa, if you like. Bit late to be going out, all the way out to, ah...’

‘Clapham,’ Lestrade supplies.

‘Yeah; right.’

Lestrade glances up, tries for a smile but ends up with something resembling pained, if sincere, gratitude. ‘Cheers. Thanks. I appreciate it, really.’

‘Yeah,’ says John. There’s an endless second of silence, then a soft, solid noise as he sets the gun back down on the table. ‘I’ll, um. I’ll just be upstairs, then.’

‘Right; yeah.’

‘Night, Greg.’

‘Goodnight, John.’

Lestrade doesn’t say anything like ‘sleep well’ or ‘I’ll see you in the morning.’ The first would be pointless, and as for the second, he just hopes the sofa is as comfortable as Sherlock’s old habits have made it out to be.

Tomorrow, he thinks, he'll quietly take the gun with him when he leaves.

When he does wake, the gun is no longer there, but John Watson is, and Lestrade supposes that’s enough, for now.

----

‘Sherlock Holmes,’ John says, ‘was a good man.’

He stops. The podium threatens to tremble under his grip.

‘He was,’ John continues a moment later, voice finally cracking, torquing into a wretched sort of whisper – the kind that Lestrade has only ever heard on broken women with broken limbs from broken homes, and tries not to think about the implications – ‘a very good man.’

John’s eyes flicker down, and his white knuckles go loose. No one moves. After the first minute of uncomposed silence, someone towards the back muffles a cough into their handkerchief.

After the third minute, John’s friend – Stanley, isn’t it? Stamford? – stands, approaches him, touches his shoulder without a word. John does not move, clearly deeply uncomfortable in his crisp white shirt, black tie, new black suit. Stamford speaks for John, dismisses the lot.

No one else speaks as the few black coats and umbrellas who had bothered to attend quietly file out much like they had filed in.

It was fitting, Lestrade supposes, stepping outside and turning up his collar at the hard wind, that the funeral for the late, great Sherlock Holmes should take only five minutes. Usually the only length of time Sherlock ever got at a crime scene, five minutes. No casket – no recovered body – no framed pictures, no flowers. Just a dozen-odd people who didn’t want to be there, in a conference room rented by the hour in the Abbey Centre, for five minutes, whilst John Watson stood silent at a podium.

Good, he could almost hear. Funerals are boring.



[identity profile] stalinglim.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 03:31 am (UTC)(link)
...God.

I sat and stared for a few minutes after reading this. And... well.

You did a fantastic job. Wow. I have no more words, I'm sorry.

[identity profile] whitmans-kiss.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 06:15 pm (UTC)(link)
Thank you very much - and don't apologize for no words! Speechless is my aim. ♥

[identity profile] zephyr-macabee.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 03:41 am (UTC)(link)
I am quite sad now. ;-;

[identity profile] whitmans-kiss.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 06:15 pm (UTC)(link)
Eep! Don't be sad!

Thank you very much. ♥

[identity profile] airynothing.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 03:43 am (UTC)(link)
Punched in the gut.

[identity profile] whitmans-kiss.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 06:16 pm (UTC)(link)
Just like Sherlock will likely be punched in the face, I'm sure.

Thank you. ♥

[identity profile] toujours-nigel.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 04:08 am (UTC)(link)
As lovely as I thought it would be, from the fragments, and just as heart-breaking.


When he comes back, what's John going to do, then?

[identity profile] whitmans-kiss.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 06:18 pm (UTC)(link)
I don't know. First, punch him in the face. Second, think he's gone mad, possibly. Third, he's going to get very drunk again. After that... I don't know.

Thank you, chiquita. ♥

[identity profile] exbex.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 04:12 am (UTC)(link)
This is stunning. Not only painful in just the right way, but you've really done justice to Lestrade.

[identity profile] whitmans-kiss.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 06:19 pm (UTC)(link)
Oh, thank you. I don't know at what point in the drafting it turned into a story just as much about Lestrade as it is about John, but I'm so glad you think I've done Lestrade well.

Thank you so much. ♥

[identity profile] missilemuse.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 04:18 am (UTC)(link)
Very powerful and moving story! You made me share that pit in my stomach with John, and you nearly made me cry… This may sound overly demanding and selfish, but you HAVE TO write a post-hiatus fic… I think we are going to need as many as possible, of those after this Sunday… And in my case, I just want to see how YOUR John would react, when Sherlock attempts to worm his way back!

[identity profile] whitmans-kiss.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 06:20 pm (UTC)(link)
Aw, I don't know about a sequel just yet. :) Still getting John over the shock of the death, just now, I think. We'll see.

Thank you so much for your kind words. It means a lot to know it had such an emotional impact. ♥

[identity profile] ceredwensirius.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 04:30 am (UTC)(link)
Ah, the queen of angst strikes again. This is really wonderful and moving and I have to admit that I too am curious to see how Sherlock worms his way back into John's embrace. Hopefully there will be a sequel.

Lovely job, bb.

[identity profile] whitmans-kiss.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 06:22 pm (UTC)(link)
Thank you so much for putting up with me going on about this fic, and for the revisions. Still the best compliment I've ever received, your advice for how to make this one better.
(deleted comment)

[identity profile] whitmans-kiss.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 06:22 pm (UTC)(link)
Thank you so much. ♥

[identity profile] shaindyl.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 05:04 am (UTC)(link)
I think that was the best 'John-after-Reichenbach' fic that I've read. The emotions were so visceral; I felt like I could reach out and touch them. I liked the fact that you didn't have John and Lestrade be good friends like they are in most fics. I think that made the emotions that much deeper because Lestrade never expected it. A real kick in the teeth, and I mean that in the best way possible.

Thanks for posting this. It was truly a pleasure to read.

[identity profile] whitmans-kiss.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 06:24 pm (UTC)(link)
I never got the impression that Lestrade and John were really buddy-buddy - this was as much exploring Lestrade's relationship with John as much as it was John's relationship to Sherlock. I'm so glad to hear that it had such an emotional impact.

Thank you, very much. ♥

(Anonymous) 2012-01-12 05:05 am (UTC)(link)
Best funeral for Sherlock Holmes I've ever read.

[identity profile] whitmans-kiss.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 06:26 pm (UTC)(link)
Thank you, kind anon. :)

That really means a lot to me to hear. ♥
innie_darling: (achievable superpower)

[personal profile] innie_darling 2012-01-12 05:56 am (UTC)(link)
Wow - Sherlock has a lot to answer for. Very nicely done.

[identity profile] whitmans-kiss.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 06:26 pm (UTC)(link)
Yes, yes he does. Bit not good, Sherlock.

Thank you very much. ♥
hagstrom: (Default)

[personal profile] hagstrom 2012-01-12 07:17 am (UTC)(link)
WHAT?
No! No! I thought there was a sequel for this, or not a sequel as such, but a "and then Sherlock came back and this happened...-sort of ending! Such a heartbreaking fic! Thank you for writing and sharing it!

[identity profile] whitmans-kiss.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 06:28 pm (UTC)(link)
Oh, my. Well, I'm not sure about a sequel, but we'll see what happens. :)

Thank you. ♥

[identity profile] yalublyutebya.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 08:07 am (UTC)(link)
This was heartbreakingly sad. Poor John. So beautifully written though, his grief and Lestrade not knowing what to say. Beautiful.

[identity profile] whitmans-kiss.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 06:29 pm (UTC)(link)
Thank you so much. I'm really glad you enjoyed it. ♥

[identity profile] lbmisscharlie.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 08:19 am (UTC)(link)
Whoa. This is amazing. One of the most heartbreaking renditions of Reichenbach I've read (and I've read a lot, I'm a sucker for angst). Well done.

[identity profile] whitmans-kiss.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 06:30 pm (UTC)(link)
Thank you so much. Reichenbach is a difficult topic, and I'm really glad you enjoyed this. ♥
disassembly_rsn: Run over by a UFO (Sherlock thoughtful)

Re: Good Man, A

[personal profile] disassembly_rsn 2012-01-12 08:40 am (UTC)(link)
That is *agonizing* - that it was supposed to be tomorrow. No wonder about John's pain, and thank God Lestrade is with him.

I'll limit myself to quoting just three particularly well-done bits, since there's no point in quoting the whole thing back:

I’ll still wear the suit, but it won’t be to -

I make it, and it just sits there in the pot all day, and I throw it out at night, and I think, what a waste it all was, what an awful, bloody, waste.

Usually the only length of time Sherlock ever got at a crime scene, five minutes.

Beautifully done.

And if Sherlock's in a classic Reichenbach scenario for this - I can't *imagine* what's going on, because the usual way that plays out just won't *fit*. (And obviously, since 'no recovered body', that's a possibility, but if so I'd dearly like to know what happened, far more than a Reichenbach scenario typically would make me want to know.) If you feel moved to write a sequel, you have a built-in audience...

Re: Good Man, A

[identity profile] whitmans-kiss.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 06:55 pm (UTC)(link)
I don't think Sherlock intended for the dates to align, but they do, and it's horrible.

We'll see about a sequel. There's Sherlock's unrecovered body, but there's also another missing body - that's not Sherlock's - in the funeral scene that also possibly sets up for one... but we'll see. :)

Thank you so much. The line about the coffee was one of the first bits of dialogue I wrote for this, and then I just had to know what the rest of the conversation was.

Thank you very, very much. It really means a lot to hear. ♥

Wow

[identity profile] hbfan2608.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 08:47 am (UTC)(link)
I actually can't speak. that was. Amazing. I want this to be canon MORE than you can ever know, even if it were just the first part, John and lestrate, sitting drinking together.

Amazing.

Re: Wow

[identity profile] whitmans-kiss.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 06:31 pm (UTC)(link)
This whole fic started with just the idea-image of John and Lestrade sitting and drinking together in 221B post-Reichenbach, so I'm glad to hear that part really resonated.

Thank you so much. ♥
lanerose: (Default)

[personal profile] lanerose 2012-01-12 09:07 am (UTC)(link)
This was impressively subtle. The little details (God, the tarp!) really sang. Well done!!

[identity profile] whitmans-kiss.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 06:36 pm (UTC)(link)
Oh, thank you so much. The tarp breaks my heart too, because it's just this weird little touch of consideration, as it also means forethought as well as having to acknowledge what comes after. Even in his what would be his last moments, John's still concerned about Mrs. Hudson and the state of the flat.

Thank you so very much. ♥

[identity profile] lotherington.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 09:49 am (UTC)(link)
Oh, darling. Darling. This was agonising and quiet and lovely and just... thank you, so much. It was absolutely beautiful - the last line brought a lump to my throat and the fact that John considered him to be a good man and argh, his memorial taking place on the day they were meant to get married and just :(. Your descriptions are so evocative as well; I loved John flexing his hand. And Lestrade was perfect.

You know how glad I am that you're writing for Sherlock and this is just as brilliant as everything else you've produced, if not more so. I can't wait to see more, love!

Thank you, thank you, thank you. ♥ You're just fantastic.

[identity profile] whitmans-kiss.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 06:38 pm (UTC)(link)
I can't really say anything to this except

*gives you giant, mad, flailing, tackling, hug*

[identity profile] paurasorridere.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 10:21 am (UTC)(link)
The only comment I have is that you don't really have to take a violin to a shop just to have it tuned unless something's wrong with it.
Well, that and this was obviously very beautiful and thank you for posting it.

[identity profile] whitmans-kiss.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 06:40 pm (UTC)(link)
Re: the violin - I did know that, but John didn't. He "played the clarinet a bit in school," so I think he doesn't really know what to do with a string instrument. :)

And thank you. ♥

[identity profile] morganstuart.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 11:37 am (UTC)(link)
Beautifully crafted. I really love what you've done with Lestrade's POV here, and your descriptions of John are remarkable and heartbreaking. Well done indeed.

[identity profile] whitmans-kiss.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 06:41 pm (UTC)(link)
I'm so glad you enjoyed it. I don't know who I hurt more for - John, or Lestrade.

Thank you very much. ♥

[identity profile] jademac2442.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 02:44 pm (UTC)(link)
Holy. Wow. That just scorched me. Was crying halfway through. Brilliant. Absolutely brilliant.

[identity profile] whitmans-kiss.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 06:42 pm (UTC)(link)
Oh, my goodness! Thank you so very much. I'm - not thrilled that you're crying, obviously, but um. I'm really glad to hear that it had such an impact.

Thank you. ♥

[identity profile] furyseed.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 03:37 pm (UTC)(link)
Clapham, heh? :-)

This was heartbreaking. And I need a f****** sequel.
You know, the one when Sherlock returns, tries to explain why he left John to believe he was dead, John pucnhes him and they get happily married, with Sherlock sporting a dark eye.

[identity profile] whitmans-kiss.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 06:45 pm (UTC)(link)
Re: Clapham - not arbitrarily picked, but I hope it suited.

Thank you so much. We'll see about a sequel - but if there was one, I'm pretty sure it'd go something along those lines. :)

Thank you. ♥

(no subject)

[identity profile] furyseed.livejournal.com - 2012-01-13 00:17 (UTC) - Expand
(deleted comment)

[identity profile] whitmans-kiss.livejournal.com 2012-01-12 06:45 pm (UTC)(link)
Thank you so very much. ♥

[identity profile] uwsannajane.livejournal.com 2012-01-13 04:10 am (UTC)(link)
Oh, dear lord, ouch! ( I suspect I'm not the first person to say that, but haven't read the other comments.)

But not just "ouch." Really, really well done. Friendship: a tiny - nearly atom-sized - speck of hope amidst the grief.

[identity profile] whitmans-kiss.livejournal.com 2012-01-13 02:16 pm (UTC)(link)
Atom-sized, but hope nonetheless.

Thank you. ♥

[identity profile] leenah.livejournal.com 2012-01-14 05:50 pm (UTC)(link)
that was awesome. cried my eyes out.

would of course love to see a sequel, w/ 'the empty house' as the kick-off point.

so much tomorrow. the repetition of tomorow (and tomorrow and tomorrow... oops, that's shakespeare) struck a nerve, no, an emotion. ouch. huge ouch.

thank you.

[identity profile] whitmans-kiss.livejournal.com 2012-01-15 01:40 am (UTC)(link)
Thank you, dear. ♥

We'll make it through the Falls.

Page 1 of 2